The Best Avocado Toast I've Ever Eaten in the East Bay Area

The Best Avocado Toast I've Ever Eaten in the East Bay Area

By Rachael Medina September 23, 2019

Nothing screams California quite like avocado toast. But not all toasts are created equal: The perfect avocado toast is achieved by creating a balance between creamy and crunchy textures, acidic and basic flavors, and bright and neutral colors. And the more avocado toast recipes we looked into, the more we realized there are a few ingredients—aside from killer bread and avocados—that can elevate a mediocre avocado toast into a work of art. 

While additional toppings aren’t absolutely necessary to craft a crave-worthy slice of toast, they definitely help to highlight the flavors of one of California’s favorite fruits. Along with high-quality bread and avocado, the most impactful ingredients for your toast include olive oil, lemon juice, sea salt, black pepper, and chili flakes. Of course, it doesn’t have to end there: Add a sprinkle of feta cheese, round it out with radishes, or perk it up with pickled onions for a burst of flavor that will please your palate.

What To Look For In Your Avocado Toast

To craft the perfect avocado toast, you'll need ripe, creamy avocados and thick slices of toasted bread—and it doesn't hurt to add a sprinkling of salt, chili flakes, or fresh herbs. 

If you’re not in the mood to make avocado toast for yourself, lucky for you, numerous restaurants can satisfy your hankering. If you go to a place where you can watch your toast being crafted in front of you, look for these indicators to see if your meal will blow you away:

1. Ripe Avocados

The avocados should be ripe (but not mushy), and the insides should be free of brown spots.

2. Toasted Bread

Thick slices of bread—particularly wheat bread—make the best bases for the rest of the toppings and add textural diversity to the creamy avocados. 

3. Salt

A pinch of salt is key; it’s glaringly obvious if it’s lacking. Sprinkle a bit on top of the toast, if needed—always taste it first. Many eateries include salt in their seasoning blends, so it might be difficult to see it, but there’s no denying taste. 

4. Properly Prepared Avocado

While this sounds like a given, the avocado should be mashed separately from the toast—if indeed the avocado is getting smashed rather than sliced—so the crunchy bread is not crushed and compromised in the process.

Where to Get The Best Avocado Toast

I’ve eaten a lot of avocado toast here in the East Bay Area. But instead of solely focusing on my favorite spots, I asked around the office to find the best East Bay eateries for avocado toast that can satiate any craving. 

Grand Lake Kitchen in Oakland is the go-to brunch spot for mouthwatering avocado toast topped with poached eggs and piquant Aleppo chili. Photo courtesy of Grand Lake Kitchen.

For Avocado Toast With Eggs: Grand Lake Kitchen, Oakland

As someone who doesn’t ordinarily get avocado toast at restaurants, it means a lot when I see one that is enticing enough to order. So, it should be obvious that the avo toast at Grand Lake Kitchen in Oakland is unlike any other. This fork-and-knife toast boasts the ultimate balance between creamy avocado, perfectly poached eggs, spicy Aleppo chili, and comforting levain bread. A nice green salad brings even more balance and value to the dish without taking away from the main event. —C., Social Media Guru

Benicia's Farm & Flour dishes up a simple yet oh-so-delicious avocado toast adorned with tangy feta, refreshing mint, zingy lemon zest, and everything bagel seasoning. Photo courtesy of Farm & Flour. 

For Simple Avocado Toast: Farm & Flour, Benicia

It doesn’t get much better than a slice of freshly baked, toasted country bread from a bakery—until you top it with avocado. Add on house-made everything bagel seasoning, lemon zest, mint, and feta cheese, and you’ve got an unforgettable slice of heaven. This fairly simple dish at Farm & Flour hits all of the bases in a creative way without distracting from the bread’s character. Fair warning: The toast is cut thick, so consider using a knife and fork if you’re on a first date. Otherwise, have at it. —H., Administrative Assistant

The health-conscious can still get their avocado-toast fix at Rooted Coffee Co in Pleasant Hill, where the popular dish is made with gluten-free bread and cashew cream cheese. Photo courtesy of Rooted Coffee Co.

For Vegan Avocado Toast: Rooted Coffee Co, Pleasant Hill

If you’re in search of a gluten-free, plant-based avocado toast, look no further than Rooted Coffee Co. Here, toasted gluten-free bread is topped with cashew cream cheese and smashed avocado before being sprinkled with salt, pepper, lemon juice, hemp seeds, and chili flakes. It’s so good with the slight spice of the chili flakes, but since it’s plant-based, it’s also guilt free. —S., Executive Assistant

In Philz Coffee's take on avocado toast, mashed avocado and slices of hard-boiled egg are perched atop a toasted slice of San Francisco sourdough, making for a hearty snack. Photo courtesy of Philz Coffee.

For Loaded Avocado Toast: Philz Coffee, Walnut Creek

The avo toast at Philz Coffee throws it back to San Francisco’s roots with a slice of sourdough bread, which is toasted to perfection and topped with smashed avocado, a drizzle of olive oil, a pinch of salt and pepper, a sprinkle of za’atar, and slices of hard-boiled egg. —C., Executive Assistant 

Starring smashed avocado, queso fresco, and cilantro on crispy sourdough, the avocado toast at Lafayette's Coffee Shop only tastes better when paired with an oat-milk latte. Photo courtesy of Coffee Shop.

For Avocado Smash & Oat-Milk Lattes: Coffee Shop, Lafayette

Coffee Shop’s avocado toast is seriously craveable. Made with simple yet fresh ingredients, this dish is perfect any time of day. The toast features perfectly chewy sourdough bread piled high with smashed avocado, lime juice, cilantro, and queso fresco—all of which is complemented by a bed of lettuce, balancing out the burst of rich flavors. Pair the avocado toast with an oat-milk latte, and there’s no better breakfast. —R., Content Manager

Though Blue Bottle Coffee is now known around the world, the company was founded in Oakland and created its first avocado toast recipe in California. Photo courtesy of Blue Bottle Coffee.

For Avo Toast & Artisanal Coffee: Blue Bottle Coffee, Oakland

While the Oakland-based Blue Bottle Coffee has opened locations across the globe, there is something comforting about knowing the coffee shop’s avocado toast recipes originated in California. The Bay Area version reigns supreme, thanks to the thick, seedy bread that supports the rest of the ingredients: mashed avocados, extra-virgin olive oil, kosher salt, lemon juice, and a combo of black pepper and chili flakes for just the right amount of kick. Go pro and put a poached egg on it, and pair it with a cup of single-origin coffee. —M., Staff Writer

0 comments


author photo
Please enter text

You may also like

Dine

Tasty Travels: Eat Your Way Through Northern California's Cheese Trail

Savor everything from authentic Italian mozzarella & French-inspired brie to sharp cheddar & beautiful blue on the California Cheese Trail....Read more

Dine

The Best Chocolate in San Francisco: An Exclusive Bay Area Chocolate Taste Test

Who has the best chocolate in San Francisco? Find out the results of California.com's exclusive Bay Area taste test....Read more

Travel

Getaway Guide: Healdsburg

From eateries to art galleries, there's a lot to do in Healdsburg. Spend a weekend here to discover a Sonoma …...Read more

Entertain

The Half Moon Bay Fall Festival You Don't Want to Miss

The 49th annual Half Moon Bay Art & Pumpkin Festival returns to the World Pumpkin Capital this October for one …...Read more